Real stories, real surprises, and what to actually expect when it’s your turn to sell.
As a Realtor, I work with a lot of first-time sellers—and almost every one of them has said the same thing: “Wow, I didn’t realize it would be like this.”
Recently, I came across a Reddit thread where people shared what they wish someone had told them before selling their home. I read through the stories, laughed, nodded, and thought: this is too good not to share. So many of my own clients have felt the exact same way—surprised, overwhelmed, emotional, and sometimes just baffled by the process.
Here are some of the most relatable and helpful takeaways.
1. Buyers will say ridiculous things. Don’t take it personally.
“The bedrooms are too small.”
“The houses are too close together.”
“It’s too far from my work.”
Even when the information is literally in the listing, you’ll still get feedback like this. One seller said it best: “Buyers are annoying—don’t take it personally.” Try to detach from the feedback. Your home is now a product, and not everyone will love it.
2. Your house does smell—even if you can’t smell it.
Especially if you have pets. Several sellers shared horror stories of cleaning their carpets only to have buyers comment on pet odor. Some ended up pulling their homes off the market to replace flooring or repaint—and it cost them.
Tip: Ask a brutally honest friend to come over and give their take before listing. Fresh air, fabric spray, and replacing anything saturated with odor can make a big difference.
3. It’s more emotional than you expect.
One seller admitted, “I’m not a crier and I 100% cried like a baby.” Letting go of the place where you’ve made so many memories can hit you hard. And that’s okay. Selling a home is a financial decision—but it’s also a big emotional one.
4. People will use your bathroom. And sometimes… not flush.
Yep, this came up a lot. You’d be amazed what buyers do during showings. Keep toilet paper stocked, clean regularly, and maybe invest in some air freshener.
5. Hide your valuables—and your medications.
Unfortunately, theft during showings is real. One seller said someone stole prescription meds. Another said people damaged things and never told the agent. Lock up anything valuable, sentimental, or private. Better yet, move it out completely if you can.
6. Don’t rely on carpet cleaning to fix everything.
In some cases, it made things worse. Steam cleaning can actually bring smells to the surface. If you’ve got lingering odors, talk to your agent about whether it’s worth replacing the carpet entirely.
7. Review the listing and photos before they go live.
Several sellers said they trusted their agent’s process only to be horrified when they saw the final listing. One said the photos made their home look dark and dated—and it cost them serious interest. Always ask to approve photos and the listing copy before launch.
8. Don’t make non-refundable plans around your closing date.
That closing date is tentative until the deal is done. Flights, movers, hotels—anything that requires a deposit—should have a backup plan. Underwriters can cause last-minute delays, or buyers can walk away during inspections.
9. Selling fast can be just as stressful as selling slow.
In a hot market, your house might sell in 48 hours—but that doesn’t mean you’re ready for what comes next. Some sellers had offers before they’d even looked at homes to move into. One said, “We were under contract and hadn’t even seen our next place yet.”
10. You’ll be cleaning constantly.
Lights will be left on. Blinds will be open. Dirt will get tracked in. Someone even left a cigarette butt on the front porch during a showing. If you can, stay elsewhere while your house is listed. If not, be prepared to tidy up every day.
Real Seller Bonus Tips
- 🧼 Clean your appliances inside and out—especially if they’re staying.
- 🚪 Replace anything you don’t plan to leave (like light fixtures or smart home devices) before listing.
- 📦 Overpack your PODS? Yep—it has a weight limit. Plan accordingly.
- 🧾 Have a CPA review your taxes if you’re selling a second home or investment property.
- 🧠 Don’t assume your DIY project looks good to buyers. They often don’t.
The bottom line:
Selling your home is a big deal. The more you plan ahead, the less stressful it will be. And if you work with a professional who prepares you for what to expect (hi 👋), you’re already a step ahead.
Thinking of selling in Jenison, Hudsonville, or anywhere in the Grand Rapids area? I’d love to help you navigate your first—or next—sale with confidence.
📩 Reach out here
🏡 Cheering you through life’s biggest moves—one milestone at a time.
Source:
This post was inspired by real stories from a Reddit thread titled First time sellers: what do you wish someone had told you to plan for when selling your house? on r/RealEstate. I read through it and had to share—so many sellers I’ve worked with have felt the exact same way.
full post
back to blog home